Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

Orders are shipped within 1-2 business days and arrive within 3-10 business days. Need it sooner? Concerned about the environmental impact? Flexible shipping options are available.

More Details

Earth Is Now Our Only Shareholder

If we have any hope of a thriving planet—much less a business—it is going to take all of us doing what we can with the resources we have. This is what we can do.

Read Yvon’s Letter

Back to Product

Men's Shearling Button Fleece Pullover Reviews

Write Your Review


True To Size

Filter Reviews

  • Runs Small
  • Kinda Small
  • True To Size
  • Kinda Large
  • Runs Large
  • 5'0 or less
  • 5'1 - 5'3
  • 5'4- 5'6
  • 5'7 - 5'9
  • 5'10 - 6'0
  • 6'1 - 6'3
  • 6'4 - 6'6
  • 6'7 or above
  • XXS
  • XS
  • S
  • M
  • L
  • XL
  • XXL
Sort By
  • Newest
  • Highest Rating
  • Lowest Rating
  • Most Votes
  • Least Votes

All 84 Reviews

Clear All

Ms Shearling Button Pullover

True To Size
September 14, 2023

Nice and soft

It's a good design and very comfortable.

September 5, 2023

Lindo buzo

Me quedo muy bien y el color es mas lindo que en la web

August 25, 2023

Never Gonna Give You Up

I cant imagine why any would have anything bad to say about this pullover. I had an old heavy weight sweatshirt I lost someplace that was my go to. Sadly it was left somewhere and never recovered. I NOW HAVE A REPLACEMENT! AND THIS TIME WITH POCKETS! Seriously this thing is great. Comfortable right out of the mailbox. Fit loose enough you could add... Read More a layer underneath and still feel like you can move. Its been washed a few times and no signs of the pilling some folks pointed out. I could care less if it did. This is a piece I would immediately buy again should anything happen to this one.

August 25, 2023

Great quality and comfort

Great quality and comfort

August 21, 2023


I had an ancient cotton/wool pullover that was getting very tattered, and no longer is made. So looking at a replacement, this seemed ideal. I initially developed a rash, even where there was no skin contact, called Patagonia, and they listened, and offered an exchange. I decided to wash it several times, and once the rash went away I wore it and t... Read Morehere were no problems. In colder weather I wear it around the house, and also while bicycling on the local trails. It is fantastic. In early May, I did a three day bike trip on the GAP (Greater Allegheny Passage) Trail, and we had what is known as weather, and this was absolutely perfect to wear. And on top of it, it looks nice.

August 10, 2023

Wished that I loved this more...(challenge on fitting)

I acquired my "first" shearling/3-button pullover (in Large size) last year and immediately loved its styling, comfort, weight, etc., -- i.e., especially the way it looked and fit. BTW, I've been a long-time Patagonia fan/customer/advocate, particularly after spending a day with founder, Yvan Chouinard in 1988. After I laundered th... Read Moree garment a couple of times (paying attention to wash/care instructions); I noticed that the pullover's fit was becoming blousy in the torso, with raglan sleeves starting to lose their elasticity. I wondered if the baggier fit was related to me (getting fitter), ...or was derived from a garment defect, ...or combination of the two factors, or...? Giving Patagonia the benefit of the doubt, I just ordered and received my next 3-button pullover, this time one-size-down (Medium) -- to address (?) the baggy/blousy issue. This new Medium size -- delivered last week, fits snugly - e.g., my wife and daughters think the "look" is more stylish; but (to me) the fit feels a bit too "close" for complete, cozier comfort. Based on this, I just ordered a Large size that I'm hoping will somehow fulfill my needs better -- i.e., with appropriate comfort, style/look, AND quality/durability in line with what I'm used to expecting from Patagonia -- i.e., before my first (baggy, deteriorated) experience with this 3-button pullover/product. I hope, and will be curious to see how /if anyone on Patagonia's service team will respond.

Response from Patagonia
August 11, 2023

Hi Larry, thank you for for letting us know about these issues. We're sorry to hear that first pullover changed the way it did! It sounds like you were doing everything right. We would consider that a warranty issue, and you're welcome to return it to us for a refund. In fact, you can [return]( any or all of these pullovers if you aren't completely satisfied with them. You can also reach out to our Customer Service Team if you'd rather combine items from different orders into a single return package. Please let us know how we can help!

April 28, 2023

My daily go-to

I absolutely love this pullover. Although it pills a bit at the sleeves, it's so comfortable that I bought three of them! I have one medium and two large, and the large fits perfectly for me. I love my clothing a little loose, so the medium felt a bit tight but definitely still wearable for my size/height.

April 26, 2023

Comfy but lacking in quality

Warm and retro-stylish with an area for improvement; the piping around the seams looks threadbare, like the garment is losing its pile. You can actually see in some of the pictures when you zoom in. At the price point I would expect near-perfection with some small caveats. I don't think anyone expects to really be taken seriously while wearing... Read More fleece, so it's forgivable, but it's something I'll pay attention to as long as I own the garment. I didn't return, but I wanted to like it more.

April 7, 2023

Super Comfortable

This shirt is cozy and warm without being overpowering. My favorite purchase from the month of March, I'm literally wearing it right now as the email prompted me to write a review.

March 14, 2023

Very comfy and soft

I just really enjoy the look and feel. Fits me perfectly, and I have longer than average arms with a short torso. Im 6 feet tall and 200 lbs. Honestly will probably get a second one just to have another color and include in my regular rotation

March 14, 2023

As advertised

Pros = looks cool af Cons = 0 Great for lounging around or use as second layer. Wind gets thru, but thats not why I bought. Can withstand SoCal winter. Have used it outdoors and sleeping. Has Sherpa-feel outside and generous pocket/hand warmer. Fabric stretches a bit so you can move around. Def a good purchase

March 12, 2023

Great product

Very happy with the purchase, fits me well. Its warm and also handles wind well.

March 11, 2023

Straggly Look

Hi, Patagonia is a great brand and I have a lot of their Tops (12) and bottom (Baggies). I love them, but even with the new button design, the product, of which I bought 2, is very ratty looking and looks very old after just a few months!

Response from Patagonia
March 15, 2023

Thank you for the review, Jon. We're sorry to hear that this fleece is not aging well. We've emailed you to set you up with a return. If you run into any other issues, we welcome you to reach out to our [customer service team](*1e10th1*_ga*MTE3MzgxOTU4OS4xNjQ3NTMxMTc0*_ga_1SYPSJZYJ5*MTY3ODg5NzQxMi42NDguMS4xNjc4ODk5MjM0LjAuMC4w). All of our items are back by our Ironclad Guarantee so if you're unhappy with a products performance, we're glad to take it back.

March 10, 2023

Top is very loose and

Top is very loose and comfortable - perfect for morning dog walks on the beach, or evenings around a fire pit.

March 5, 2023

Super ineffective

Looks nice, fits well, liked the buttons and collar. Poor insulator even under a wind breaker.

Response from Patagonia
March 9, 2023

Hi Ed, we're very sorry to hear that the Shearling Fleece Button Pullover is meeting your needs regarding warmth. If you're looking for a warmer fleece, we suggest checking out our line of [Better Sweaters](

February 28, 2023

The collar style was a dealbreaker

I was looking for a warm fleece quarter zip; something warmer than a Better Sweater (although I do like the look of those). The shearling was warm and comfortable and I enjoyed the kangaroo pocket. I ordered it online. Once I tried it on, I realized that the collar style was not attractive to me. The Synchilla ended up being a better choice.

February 27, 2023

Perfect pullover

I love this. It's the perfect size and the pockets are a great addition. It's soft and roomy, and goes with everything. I didn't realize it was navy on the trim until I got outside in the sunlight - the lighting inside the store isn't the greatest. Still, it's great.

February 27, 2023

Receive multi compliments on color

Receive multi compliments on color and fit! Easy to get into and out of it. Super comfortable in recent Santa Barbara cold snap with snow. This was a gift from my daughter. Good taste, like her father!

February 26, 2023

Super Comfortable!

Love this jacket! Very versatile and keeps you warm :)

February 23, 2023

Runs loose and a bit stretch already

I love the brand and I am a loyal customer but this jacket is not what I expected. It is mainly on the waist, that already is seems to be a bit stretch out. Also the chest is a weird fit.

Response from Patagonia
March 1, 2023

Hello Fernando, thank you for the review. We're sorry to hear that this fleece has been a disappointment overall. You're welcome to send it back for a refund or merchandise credit. For other options in men's fleece, [click here](

February 22, 2023

Warm and comfortable

I bought this for my teenage grandson and his first comment was he was going to wear it all the time! Great weight and fit (he is 6feet tall, narrow waist but broad shoulders). Medium is a perfect fit.

February 20, 2023

Softest piece I own.

Super comfy!

February 17, 2023

This fleece is relatively light

This fleece is relatively light weight compared to others I've tried but that was the point. Ironically, it actually weighs more because of the knit cuffs and bottom hem that add overall weight and do a good job holding warmth in (just as the specs say). It also has real pockets, which is great. In retrospect Id like to have had a zip closure ... Read Morerather than the buttons what are sorta clunky. (Id also appreciate a Comment box that would take appostrophes!) All in all, a good purchase.

February 15, 2023


Very comfortable very stylish button up. The material is a little thin but warm nonetheless. A little tight around the shoulders (I have broad shoulders). All around great coat with durable polyester.

February 13, 2023

Good fit , warm, soft

Good fit , warm, soft

February 9, 2023

Outstanding Sweater

This is a sweater that looks great for casual wear and is surprisingly warm. Texture is soft, easy to get on and off. It is so good I am very tempted to get another one in a different color.

February 9, 2023

Terrific design and great fit

I am 6-3 / 240 and this fit perfect. I love the button collar, the buttons are on solidly and the collar is very comfortable.

February 9, 2023

I have a Patagonia fleece

I have a Patagonia fleece top in size medium which I bought 15-20 years ago that was comfortably warm but too snug. This is a replacement and I havent used it enough to make a decision about it yet.

February 7, 2023

Warm but too wide and baggy compared to length

While I liked the color of the brown and navy, the pockets really ruin the overall fit of the pullover. It would look so much more flattering and hang less awkwardly and baggy on you if the lower torso where the pockets are was instead a little snugger. I have a bit of a gut and even for me it was too wide on me and could've been longer too. Y... Read Moreou really need minimum 2 layers under it for it to fit normally, and at that point I'd just wear a jacket.

January 31, 2023

Cozy and nice looking!

Very cozy and warm! I got one for my husband and another for my brother in law. Had to size up as it runs a bit short. A nice change from the typical quarter zip.

January 26, 2023

Cozy and retro

One of my favorite casual layers for around town, in the house, or under my ski jacket. Warm, soft, and cool retro style. Im 5 foot 9, 165-175 lbs (muscular build- 42 chest, 31 waist) and the size L fits perfectly. The older model was slightly loose at the waist but this newer model seems slightly more fitted which I like. Love the pink accents ins... Read Moreide the collar on the blue/teal colorway. Might get a third of this fleece next time they hit a sale :)

January 22, 2023

Ultra Cozy

I was in search of something a little more elevated than the snap T but just as comfortable. Warm, roomy but looks good if you need to bust it out at the office. Pockets are classic hoody pockets so it weights down right in the middle, could be cool if next version has more of a jacket style pockets to balance out the weight.

January 15, 2023

Not up to Patagonias usual quality standard

Found the fabric too thin and not the usual Patagonia quality, especially at this price point. Sadly it felt cheap and flimsy. Returned.

Response from Patagonia
January 26, 2023

Hi Jennifer, thank you for submitting this feedback, and for returning a pullover that wasn't going to make you happy. We're sorry it was disappointing! You might prefer one of our beefier fleeces, like the Retro Pile line. Please give us a call if we can help!

January 5, 2023


Gave as a gift. Fit well, he likes it. I will note that the brown color looks lighter in person.

January 5, 2023

Very Comfortable

The feel is comforting, especially nice for walking outside on a cool morning. Does a very good job at keeping the body warm and looks very nice as well, highly recommended!

December 31, 2022

Loved it

Loved it

December 27, 2022

Bought this for my 16

Bought this for my 16 yr old son and he absolutely loves it! What more could you want than a roomy pullover sweater that is snuggle soft.

December 2, 2022

Really cozy

Hi V

November 27, 2022

Narrow Shoulders

Tried this on in the Boulder CO super store. I have a dozen or so fleece tops and such from Patagonia, and I'm typically perfect for their medium size (6'1", 170 pounds, 34" arms. Even the large felt a bit constrained in my shoulders, so this doesn't work for me. Only reason for the 4 stars is that it's fit seems very ... Read Moredifferent from what typically is very uniform sizing. Very disappointed since I love pullover fleeces with pockets and was so ready to buy this, but this still looked to be an outstanding garment!

November 18, 2022

The best

The best fleece, the brown and navy combo is iconic and the quarter buttons is a classy look. Super warm and comfy. Buy true to size. I'm 5'11" 200lbs and the large fits perfect, hope this helps

November 13, 2022

Great work and active ware

Great fit, warm and works well for work and hiking.

November 11, 2022

Love it!

Loved it when I tried it for the first time. Super warm and comes in attractive colors. You can wear them on a hike and dress it up for the office because of the buttoned collar.

October 19, 2022

Preparing for winter

Winter mountaineering and hiking are a thing of the past for me. but dealing with mild winter conditions outdoors and lower temp settings indoors give me pause so I decided to try the Shearling fleece pullover. I now have three of them. Comfortable and toasty, they are perfect for my needs. My only concern, and time will tell, is whether or not the... Read More garment will develop piling around the collar. There is some indication on my oldest one.

October 15, 2022

Fantastic product! Super warm and comfy.

I really love the sweater. Its pretty thin, so it easy to get under a ski jacket or pair of waders. Keeps you nice and warm. I love the 1/4 button up. All around love it

October 8, 2022

Loved It, But Had to Return It

Instantly wanted this when I saw it. The colors are perfect - especially the wine and navy grosgrain ribbon accents - but even before I bought it, I was worried there might be a fit issue with the side pockets. As with many garments like this, the side pockets 'pouf out,' and with the knit navy trim on the oatmeal background, it made my a... Read Morebdomen look distended. Patagonia, please let me know if you ever make this exact same style pullover without the side pockets, and I will gladly buy it. But with regret, this one wasn't for me.

September 22, 2022


It's weird. It's whatever temperature it needs to be. Never hot or cold. I love it!

September 17, 2022

Great fleece

I bought this item at the Freeport, Maine store so I could try it on. I found that in the store, the quantity of mens items were more plentiful and less expensive. This fleece pullover fits me perfectly. I normally wear a women's large in a Patagonia fleece pullover. The quality is top notch and I love the front pocket that will keep my hands ... Read Morewarm in colder weather. Highly recommended.

September 16, 2022

Loose collar

I dont like the collar. It lays flat. Model photos show a collar that stays up.just looks completely different than photos.

Response from Patagonia
September 27, 2022

Hi Bryan! Thank you for taking the time to write us a review. We're really sorry to hear about the disappointment with the collar. We really appreciate this feedback as it's crucial to improving products for future seasons. Your satisfaction is always guaranteed so you're welcome to [return](

September 14, 2022

Best designed, best made

I purchased my first pull over with through pocket/pouch 30+ years ago. Marsupials and baggies are the best.

September 10, 2022

My New "Go-To" Fleece

I own four different Patagonia fleece pull-overs, but this 1/4-button pull-over with the marsupial pocket (nice feature) looks to be my new go-to Fall and Winter garment. It already looks awesome with just a T-shirt underneath for both my collar-need work dress requirement and cool-looking casual wear - real easy to pull on and off - and is just th... Read Moree right weight and soft feel. GREAT job, Patagonia !

August 26, 2022

perfect for chilly california mornings

This thing is so cozy, and very retro-stylish. Im 5 foot 9 and weigh around 170-180 pounds (muscular build) and the L fits perfectly. Just got it and have worn it casually for the last couple days, but excited to use this before morning surf sessions and for a snow layer.

July 28, 2022

Warm and a great fit

Great fit and warm

June 18, 2022

So warm and super comfy

Bought this for camping and hiking in Washington state. Wore under a rain jacket and kept me super warm. Was extra comfortably when sitting around the campfire later. Doesnt hurt that its stylish as all hell.

April 29, 2022

Womens version has a far better fit

Bought this for my husband The waist band, buttons & pockets made it a very snug fit. The womens style fits far better w/out the waist band etc

Response from Patagonia
May 3, 2022

Thank you for sharing this review, Becca. We're sorry to hear that fit didn't work for him! Please let us know if we can help at all with that return.

March 31, 2022

Very nice

Fits well. Comfortable and warm

March 27, 2022

Just Great

Awesome very soft and warm

March 17, 2022


Pleased with the fit/drape. Fleece very different as all recycled. "Pouch" much more substantial than previous versions. Looking forward to wearing this garment frequently.

January 24, 2022

Super comfortable

Bought one and loved it. Ordered another one in different color. Warm but comfortable even inside.

January 10, 2022

So soft and warm

Fit is true to size.

December 31, 2021

Love the fleece

I love it, the fleece is so thick and soft. the fit is perfect to wear with a light weight shirt underneath.

December 30, 2021

Classy and cozy

I bought this for my husband and hes not taken it off since Christmas. Its classy and fitted enough for him to wear to work with khakis and also wear with jeans/joggers.

December 26, 2021

Great Look

Great men's pullover, would highly recommend.

December 25, 2021

Love the fleece

The material is perfect, nice and soft great quality. Love the style. Perfect for wearing over other light weight shirt only because it's a little oversized. If getting again and wearing without other shirt underneath might size down. But its great as it is.

December 2, 2021


Looks great, feels great, fits great!

November 21, 2021


Awesome, nice fleece on the dressy kind so nice and cozy, also the folks at Patagonia online and in my local store in Mn are so nice. Thank you Shawn E

November 19, 2021


Simply the nicest thick semi dressy and casual looking and feeling fleece out there, super warm. the folks at Patagonia online help and my local store in Minnesota are the best. Thank You Shawn E

November 16, 2021

Soft and comfortable

Love this piece. I throw it on and wear it all day, in and out of doors. Made of a unique stretch material great for movements such as physical work and fly casting. Layers well under a shell, toasty warm and lightweight. Exchanged a large for a medium and it's a better fit.

November 14, 2021

Runs big

I usually wear a large in most tops, this runs really big and baggy.

November 14, 2021

Fits one size small

I selected my size based on the picture of the models who were my height that were wearing size mediums. The waist of the sweater has a tendency to fit higher on the waist and feels short. However, fabric and material are fantastic.

November 5, 2021

good buy

Great item. gets lots of complements. I will mention everything on this website has fit me as a small but this one I had to get a medium. I am 6' 0" pretty slim if anyone else is similar I recommend a medium

November 3, 2021

Great fleece

Super warm and stylish fleece

October 20, 2021

Soft and comfortable

Great piece. I can wear it out on the boat guiding or in the office. Always love the pile garments - warm in the wind with minimal layers underneath. Sholders are too broad for a medium to be comfortable so I usually have to size up for more room and it fits perfectly.

October 12, 2021

Thick, High Quality

I'm 6'2" and purchased a size "Large" and it fits extremely well; not too small, not too large. It's also quite warm for this unseasonable snow here in Montana.

October 11, 2021

Comfortable and Warm

Casual but nice looking, very warm and comfy, well made.

September 13, 2021

Checks All the Boxes

This fleece offers everything I wanted -- oatmeal color, attractive trim, large buttons, high neck coverage, warm, lightweight, and quality fabric. As important, I enjoy buying from an organization that walks their talk and places integrity and social values front & center, Well played!

September 2, 2021


Love it, solid design and warmth

June 13, 2021

At least pictures are pretty

I've had snap Tees for years and loved them. I thought this would be the similar but with an updated look. WRONG! Patagonia usually hits it out of the park. For me this was a strike out. I ordered a large but it just seemed too tight in the shoulders and I could not button it up. I reordered an XL and it did give me much better movement howeve... Read Morer the neck was still too tight. I think having the buttons offset was not a good idea. What really was a deal killer for me was the 'elastic' waistband. It was poorly constructed, stretched out and absolutely non functioning. Looked and felt horrid. To spend that much money I expected more you you guys.... but hey, nobody's perfect. But you are usually are pretty damn close.

Response from Patagonia
June 15, 2021

Thanks for the honest feedback here Ernest. We hope you do find something that works for you.

April 9, 2021

All the compliments

Im so fluffy!

March 26, 2021

Super warm.

Wife bought for me. Now my go to for hiking.

March 21, 2021

A level above....

Have a collection of Patagonia Synchilla Snap pullovers... The Shearling Pullover is a level above in fit and finish... GREAT JOB

August 10, 2019

Awesome Material

Comfy, durable and well made. A+

May 8, 2019

Very well made, feels like

Very well made, feels like a million bucks !

May 8, 2019

Comfortable and warm

Great product. Soft and very warm for New England weather

February 8, 2019

Lovely jackets

Lovely jacket! Gives a comfort feeling on the body all day lon

Sorry, no reviews match your criteria. Clear or modify your filters and try again.

Popular searches