Atlantic Salmon Net Pens Don’t Belong in Puget Sound

Kurt Beardslee  /  7 Min Read  /  Activism

On September 16, 2017, people from all over Washington State brought kayaks, canoes, fishing boats, motor boats, paddle boards, jet skis, sailboats and more out to the southern coast of Bainbridge Island to peacefully protest Atlantic salmon net pens in Puget Sound. Photo: John Gussman

Amidst all of the commotion, the subtle shift would have been easy to miss. Behind me in the waters off the coast of Washington’s Bainbridge Island, an armada of activists were blaring air horns and chanting, “Protect Our Sound!” This flotilla of commercial fishing vessels, recreational boats, kayaks, canoes, SUPs and even a jet ski had converged on the Governor’s hometown to send a loud and clear message that Atlantic salmon net pens don’t belong in Washington’s waters.

As empowering as this demonstration was, what was perhaps more uplifting was the steady flow of Washingtonians who interrupted their Saturday park stroll to inquire about the protest. Two months ago, most of these folks would not have known that Puget Sound is home to eight Atlantic salmon net pens, even though one of these floating factory farms is only 100 feet off the coast of the park. But that all changed on August 21st when a net pen breached and released more than 100,000 farmed Atlantic salmon into the sound.

Photo: John Gussman

Photo: John Gussman

https://vimeo.com/234434746

Finding the silver lining of an environmental catastrophe is often harder than finding a needle in a haystack, but these conversations made the silver lining obvious. For years we’ve worked to raise awareness about this issue and have struggled to break through all of the noise. Finally, the extensive news coverage of this disaster has captured the public’s attention and enraged them. As a result, conversations that for years began with a lengthy explanation about the danger of net pens now begin with excited questions from people about how they can help.

And boy, do we need their help. In the aftermath of the spill, Governor Inslee instructed the Department of Ecology to put a hold on any new permits for net pens until a thorough investigation of the escapement is completed. This directive is no doubt a victory but make no mistake, it is just a temporary moratorium, not a permanent ban.

Photo courtesy of Our Sound, Our Salmon

Over the weekend of August 19, 2017, a large escapement of Atlantic salmon occurred in the Deepwater Bay off of Cypress Island. The escape of non-native Atlantic salmon poses a massive threat to native wild fish in the Northwest, and to the ecosystem at large. Photo courtesy of Our Sound, Our Salmon

Washington’s extensive 30-year record of supporting this industry and one unfortunate state mandate give us every reason to expect that once the dust settles, the state will revert back to its net-pen-friendly ways unless we can pressure them not to. And pressure them we must because the net pen industry is on the precipice of a massive expansion that will reverberate for generations.

For years, a Washington-based company called Icicle Seafoods owned and operated all eight net pens in Puget Sound. However, in 2016 Cooke Aquaculture, an international corporation with major salmon farm operations in Chile, Spain, Scotland, Canada and Maine, purchased Icicle. Following the purchase, Cooke unveiled their ambitious plan to transform this relatively small operation into one that replaces all U.S. imports of Chilean farmed salmon with salmon farmed in Washington.

To make that happen, Cooke claims they would need to ramp up annual production from 15 million pounds to 200 million pounds. Expanding their production by more than 1,300 percent would require building an additional 340 acres of net pens in Puget Sound and the Strait of Juan de Fuca. Eight net pens is already eight too many. If Cooke’s plan becomes our reality, the future of Puget Sound and its wild salmon will be bleak.

Photo courtesy of Our Sound, Our Salmon

Puget Sound was once home to some of the greatest Pacific salmon populations in the world. While wild salmon populations are now only a fraction of their historic abundance, these majestic fish are still an ecological cornerstone for Puget Sound and all the salmon-bearing rivers that flow into it. Photo courtesy of Our Sound, Our Salmon

It is important to note that while the coverage of this massive escapement brought to light the horror of Atlantic salmon net pens, this catastrophe was by no means an aberration or even the greatest threat these factory farms pose. In 1996, 1997 and 1999, catastrophic escapements resulted in the release of 591,000 net-pen-raised Atlantic salmon according to the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife. In addition to these widely publicized incidents, net pens also pose a series of less visible, pernicious threats that endanger our sound and our wild salmon on a daily basis.

Washington’s lax regulations and the industry’s lack of transparency make it hard to quantify the total impact of Atlantic salmon net pens in Puget Sound. However, we do know these net pens have a poor safety record that includes a major viral outbreak, the spread of lethal parasites, significant use of toxic chemicals and decades of pollution. This history of destruction is consistent with the global track record of Atlantic salmon net pens, which have wreaked havoc on ecosystems and wild fish populations everywhere they operate, from Norway to British Columbia to Chile.

Atlantic Salmon Net Pens Don’t Belong in Puget Sound

View full-sized image. Infographic courtesy of Our Sound, Our Salmon

In the wake of the most recent environmental tragedy perpetrated by the net pen industry, Washington faces a major decision. Fundamentally, this decision is a gut check that will illuminate the state’s priorities and demonstrate how much it values Puget Sound and its iconic wild salmon.

Option one is for the state to continue its long support of the net pen industry and enable Cooke’s plans to transform Puget Sound into a global epicenter of net pen production. I am by no means a prophet but based on the mountain of scientific evidence that has been generated by net pen operations across the world, I feel confident predicting this option does not bode well for Puget Sound and its salmon.

Option two is to follow in the footsteps of California, Oregon and Alaska, which do not allow the Atlantic salmon net pen industry to operate in their waters. We know enough to know that the costs of this industry far outweigh the benefits. And we value Puget Sound enough to prioritize its future health and well being over the future profits of an international net pen conglomerate. The only question is whether or not we will do that.

Photo: John Gussman

Photo: John Gussman

The Our Sound, Our Salmon campaign is working to make this decision an obvious and easy one for the State of Washington. This collaborative campaign has forged a robust coalition consisting of more than 80 businesses, commercial fishing operations and conservation organizations as well as 10,000 individuals. Together we are igniting a powerful grassroots campaign that is fighting to determine the future of our sound and our salmon.

The August 21 escapement that flooded Puget Sound with more than 100,000 thousand diseased and deformed Atlantic salmon was a tragedy that will have major repercussions for years to come. However, we have the opportunity to transform this tragedy into triumph by converting the heightened awareness this tragedy generated into widespread action.

Ultimately, the future of Puget Sound and its salmon is in our hands. It’s time for us to stand up for our sound. It’s time for us to stand up for our salmon. And it’s time we stand up for our children’s future by stopping the expansion of destructive Atlantic salmon net pens in Puget Sound.

Take Action Today!

Please join Patagonia, more than 80 other businesses/organizations, as well as the 10,000 individuals who are standing up for our sound and our salmon. Please sign our petition to Governor Inslee asking him to stop the expansion of net pens in Puget Sound and visit the Our Sound, Our Salmon website to learn about other opportunities to support this critical campaign.

Sign the Petition

Campaign update (March 5, 2018): We are please to report the Washington State Senate voted to approve EHB2957, a bill that will phase out Atlantic salmon net pens in Puget Sound. This is a significant victory for wild salmon! To learn more about the decision, visit the Our Sound, Our Salmon Facebook page and read this article in The Seattle Times

Related Stories

Saving One River: Hoh Steelhead in Decline
“Nature provides a free lunch, but only if we control our appetites.” —William Ruckelshaus, first administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency A coho salmon the size of my pinky drifts quietly in the shade. It’s hardly distinguishable from the sand below. But Marie-France Roy, a professional snowboarder who does volunteer habitat- enhancement work in her hometown…
“Nature provides a free lunch, but only if we control our appetites.” —William Ruckelshaus, first administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency A coho salmon the size of my pinky drifts quietly in the shade. It’s hardly distinguishable from the sand below. But Marie-France Roy, a professional snowboarder who does volunteer habitat- enhancement work in her hometown…
Colin Wiseman
10 min Read
Senator Tom Udall on the Hope of Wildlife Corridors
As the great Aldo Leopold once said, harmony with the land and with wildlife “is like harmony with a friend; you cannot cherish his right hand and chop off his left.” Yet here we are: humankind is now the singular driving force behind the potential extinction of more than one million species, according to the…
As the great Aldo Leopold once said, harmony with the land and with wildlife “is like harmony with a friend; you cannot cherish his right hand and chop off his left.” Yet here we are: humankind is now the singular driving force behind the potential extinction of more than one million species, according to the…
Senator Tom Udall
4 min Read
Grizzlies, Corn, and the Urgency of Protecting Wildlife Corridors
This was the rule of late summer in Montana’s Mission Valley: During the day, the landscape belonged to humans. Tractors worked the fields, and children played carefree in the yards. People swam in shady eddies and picnicked beside the creeks. At night, the bears came out. Stretching in the cooling twilight, the grizzlies left their…
This was the rule of late summer in Montana’s Mission Valley: During the day, the landscape belonged to humans. Tractors worked the fields, and children played carefree in the yards. People swam in shady eddies and picnicked beside the creeks. At night, the bears came out. Stretching in the cooling twilight, the grizzlies left their…
Bryce Andrews
8 min Read
Standing Up Against Industrial Fish Farming at a Unique Australian Beachbreak
Standing Up Against Industrial Fish Farming That Would Forever Alter A Unique Australian Beachbreak The day we arrived on King Island we drove out to Martha Lavinia Beach, where we stood in the dunes and watched waves running down the beach—long left-handers breaking so fast they were almost impossible to surf. However, Martha Lavinia wasn’t…
Standing Up Against Industrial Fish Farming That Would Forever Alter A Unique Australian Beachbreak The day we arrived on King Island we drove out to Martha Lavinia Beach, where we stood in the dunes and watched waves running down the beach—long left-handers breaking so fast they were almost impossible to surf. However, Martha Lavinia wasn’t…
Sean Doherty
6 min Read
Doug Peacock’s Fight for That Last Bear: Ben Moon’s “Grizzly Country”
Is it possible you’re reading this on The Cleanest Line and it’s the first you’re hearing of Doug Peacock? Is that even possible? Well, if so, you’re in for a real treat. In his latest film, Grizzly Country, Ben Moon creates a portrait of Peacock—a man who’s long been willing to put life and limb…
Is it possible you’re reading this on The Cleanest Line and it’s the first you’re hearing of Doug Peacock? Is that even possible? Well, if so, you’re in for a real treat. In his latest film, Grizzly Country, Ben Moon creates a portrait of Peacock—a man who’s long been willing to put life and limb…
Patagonia
2 min Read
Path of the Puma
Arcilio Sepulveda used to hunt pumas for a living. Today he’s a key member of the Tompkins Conservation wildlife recovery program, helping to protect an expanding population of mountain lions in Patagonia National Park in Chile. Formerly a “leonero,” a lion killer who lived on a huge estancia that raised sheep and cattle, Arcilio was…
Arcilio Sepulveda used to hunt pumas for a living. Today he’s a key member of the Tompkins Conservation wildlife recovery program, helping to protect an expanding population of mountain lions in Patagonia National Park in Chile. Formerly a “leonero,” a lion killer who lived on a huge estancia that raised sheep and cattle, Arcilio was…
Cristián Saucedo, D.V.M D.V.M
5 min Read
Rewilding Iberá
It’s spring in the wetlands of Iberá, and two young jaguar cubs appear filled with trepidation and curiosity as they follow their mother, Tania, into the water for their first swim. Aramí, which means “little sky” in the native Guaraní language, and Mbareté, or “strong,” are the first cubs born in Tompkins Conservation’s Jaguar Experimental…
It’s spring in the wetlands of Iberá, and two young jaguar cubs appear filled with trepidation and curiosity as they follow their mother, Tania, into the water for their first swim. Aramí, which means “little sky” in the native Guaraní language, and Mbareté, or “strong,” are the first cubs born in Tompkins Conservation’s Jaguar Experimental…
Sebastián Di Martino
4 min Read
Judge Ends Grizzly Hunts with Ruling That’s Bigger Than Bears
So far in this young century, few wildlife conservation issues have galvanized more Americans than whether or not Western state governments ought to allow grizzly bears to be hunted again. On Monday, September 24, 2018, U.S. District Judge Dana L. Christensen in Missoula, Montana, resolved the matter for the foreseeable future. In a 48-page decision,…
So far in this young century, few wildlife conservation issues have galvanized more Americans than whether or not Western state governments ought to allow grizzly bears to be hunted again. On Monday, September 24, 2018, U.S. District Judge Dana L. Christensen in Missoula, Montana, resolved the matter for the foreseeable future. In a 48-page decision,…
Todd Wilkinson
6 min Read
Popular searches