There is Trump and There is the Truth

Corley Kenna  /  4 Min Read  /  Activism

Yesterday, the president didn’t just reduce the boundaries of your public lands. He revoked two national monuments. No president has ever done that before. It is widely unpopular and unprecedented. It is also illegal, and Patagonia will be challenging his action in court.

The president also lied. Here is a fact-check of his speech:

TRUMP: And that is why I’m here today: Because some people think that the natural resources of Utah should be controlled by a small handful of very distant bureaucrats located in Washington. And guess what? They’re wrong.

TRUTH: National Monuments are managed by public servants that live and work in the surrounding county, and that wasn’t changed by President Obama’s action or President Trump’s action. And when Secretary Zinke asked the country what they wanted, 98% of almost 3 million people said to leave the protections in place.

TRUMP: … I’m a real estate developer. When they start talking about millions of acres, I say, say it again? That’s a lot. So, before I began, I met with Senator Orrin Hatch, who loves Utah and loves the people of Utah. I called Senator Mike Lee, who loves Utah and loves the people of Utah. I called your governor … I called all of the friends that I have in Utah. I said, what do you think? I said, will this be good for our country, and will it be good for your state? They said this would be incredible for our country, will be incredible for Utah. Finally, you would be giving people back their access to the land they know, to the land they understand, and most importantly, to the land that they love.

TRUTH: Eliminating national monument protections opens these areas to mining, oil and gas development, road building and other destruction. It’s incontrovertible that selling off the rights to these lands benefits the few and not the many.

TRUMP: These actions will modify the national monuments designations of both Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante.

TRUTH: The president is not modifying Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante Monuments. He is rescinding them. See map here.

TRUMP: As many of you know, past administrations have severely abused the purpose, spirit, and intent of a century-old law known as the Antiquities Act. This law requires that only the smallest necessary area be set aside for special protection as national monuments. Unfortunately, previous administrations have ignored the standard and used the law to lock up hundreds of millions of acres of land and water under strict government control.

TRUTH:  Since it was signed into law by Teddy Roosevelt, presidents of both parties have used the Antiquities Act to protect some of America’s most prized outdoor spaces. Thanks to the Antiquities Act, the Grand Canyon, Olympic, Acadia, Arches, and dozens of other national parks were first protected. Of America’s 59 national parks, 28 were first protected or expanded as national monuments by presidents under the Antiquities Act.

Furthermore, not only do protected public lands power an $887 billion outdoor economy and support 7.6 million jobs, but protected areas also significantly boost the economies of communities nearby. Studies show that rural areas in the West close to protected federal lands perform better on average than areas without protected federal lands in a variety of economic measures, including per capita income and employment.

TRUMP: Here, and in other affected states, we have seen harmful and unnecessary restrictions on hunting, ranching, and responsible economic development. We have seen grazing restrictions prevent ranching families from passing their businesses and beloved heritage on to the children—the children that they love.

TRUTH: Hunting and ranching is allowed at both the Bears Ears and the Grand Staircase Escalante National Monuments. National Monument status only prevents new drilling, mining and fracking. In fact, Secretary Zinke’s own briefing materials indicate that grazing inside of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument has not changed since the late-1990s, when it was initially protected. And sportsmen’s groups have continually advocated for protecting prime hunting lands as national monuments to ensure high-quality habitat is maintained into the future.

TRUMP: We have seen how this tragic federal overreach prevents many Native Americans from having their rightful voice over the sacred land where they practice their most important ancestral and religious traditions.

TRUTH: Five sovereign Indian nations and their inter-tribal coalition came together to support the protection of Bears Ears. On June 23, 2016, the coalition wrote: “The Bears Ears region faces urgent threats from looting and vandalism. Destructive uranium, oil and gas, and potash mining projects are being proposed. Unnecessary and damaging roads are on the drawing boards. Protection for this important cultural landscape cannot be delayed any longer. We are more certain than ever that the best path forward to protect the Bears Ears region, and for a meaningful Tribal role in collaboratively managing the area is for President Obama to designate a Bears Ears National Monument.”

On Dec. 4, 2017, the Navajo Nation vowed to challenge President Trump’s action in court. “We will stand and fight all the way,” said Russell Begaye, president of the Navajo Nation, adding that the United States government had already taken “millions of acres of my people’s land.” “We have suffered enough,” he said.

TRUMP: These abuses of the Antiquities Act have not just threatened your local economies; they’ve threatened your very way of life. They’ve threatened your hearts.

TRUTH: Protected lands are a proven economic driver in Utah. The communities around the Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument have seen robust growth since the area was first protected in 1996. Just from 2000 to 2015, the local communities saw jobs grow by 24%, real income grew by 34%, and per capita income grew by 17%. Multiple new hotels and businesses have opened in recent years.

TRUMP: Our precious national treasures must be protected. And they, from now on, will be protected.

TRUTH: With his action, President Trump ordered the largest elimination of protections for public lands in our country’s history. Revoking Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monuments removes protections from national treasures and could lead to their permanent destruction. We need more protected land, not less.

To learn more and take action, visit patagonia.com/protect-public-lands.

Related Stories

Keepers of a Way of Life: Gwich’in Youth’s Role in Protecting the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge
In the Arctic, Gwich’in youth are learning that protecting land means preserving a way of life. On Alaska’s North Slope, where polar bears den and gray wolves howl, protecting the land isn’t about supporting a cause or posting on social media from a protest at city hall. Here, it’s a matter of survival. Jewels Gilbert…
In the Arctic, Gwich’in youth are learning that protecting land means preserving a way of life. On Alaska’s North Slope, where polar bears den and gray wolves howl, protecting the land isn’t about supporting a cause or posting on social media from a protest at city hall. Here, it’s a matter of survival. Jewels Gilbert…
Lisset Fun
10 min Read
Where Life Begins: Patagonia Ambassadors Explore the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge
 
Clare Gallagher
5 min Read
A Day at the Yosemite Facelift Cleanup
On an incredibly clear, early autumn morning, the aging Yosemite Search and Rescue (YOSAR) van bumped along Tioga Pass Road, taking precariously tight turns at an alarming speed. Twelve of us were crammed in the back, chattering and bracing ourselves against the van’s interior walls. When the road was no longer passable for vehicles, we…
On an incredibly clear, early autumn morning, the aging Yosemite Search and Rescue (YOSAR) van bumped along Tioga Pass Road, taking precariously tight turns at an alarming speed. Twelve of us were crammed in the back, chattering and bracing ourselves against the van’s interior walls. When the road was no longer passable for vehicles, we…
Jane Jackson
7 min Read
The Magic of the Desert
The creation of Bears Ears National Monument was something that seemed more inevitable in the summer of 2016. It seems like now it’s one of those things where you’re on one side or the other because after all, I’m writing this book in the Trump years, and no one is getting along or in the…
The creation of Bears Ears National Monument was something that seemed more inevitable in the summer of 2016. It seems like now it’s one of those things where you’re on one side or the other because after all, I’m writing this book in the Trump years, and no one is getting along or in the…
Luke Mehall
5 min Read
Welcome to Gwichyaa Zhee: A Conversation with Co-Director Len Necefer
Indigenous communities across the United States are increasingly confronted with threats to their sovereignty and to the places they rely on for their culture and way of life. Nowhere is this threat felt more than in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. A new short film, Welcome to Gwichyaa Zhee, looks at the Gwich’in people’s work to protect…
Indigenous communities across the United States are increasingly confronted with threats to their sovereignty and to the places they rely on for their culture and way of life. Nowhere is this threat felt more than in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. A new short film, Welcome to Gwichyaa Zhee, looks at the Gwich’in people’s work to protect…
Madalina Preda
9 min Read
Hey, How’s That Lawsuit Against the President Going?
Glad you asked … and if you aren’t already aware, in December 2017, President Trump issued a proclamation slashing Utah’s Bears Ears National Monument by 85 percent and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, 100 miles to the west of Bears Ears, by half. In an unprecedented response, we joined a coalition of Native American and grassroots groups…
Glad you asked … and if you aren’t already aware, in December 2017, President Trump issued a proclamation slashing Utah’s Bears Ears National Monument by 85 percent and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, 100 miles to the west of Bears Ears, by half. In an unprecedented response, we joined a coalition of Native American and grassroots groups…
Patagonia
4 min Read
The Shutdown Isn’t Over
For 34 days in December and January, the government shutdown not only impaired the livelihoods of 800,000 federal employees, it brought almost the entire federal scientific apparatus to a halt. Worse, there are indicators that the Trump administration willingly took advantage of the shutdown to expedite strategic projects in the oil and gas, mining, and…
For 34 days in December and January, the government shutdown not only impaired the livelihoods of 800,000 federal employees, it brought almost the entire federal scientific apparatus to a halt. Worse, there are indicators that the Trump administration willingly took advantage of the shutdown to expedite strategic projects in the oil and gas, mining, and…
Elliott Woods
10 min Read
Two Grand Canyon Trekkers on Conserving Its Precious Silence
As gorgeous as the Grand Canyon is to look upon, its greatest gifts may not be visual. “On any given evening in summer, but most notably in late June, there comes a moment just after the sun has disappeared behind the rimrock, and just before the darkness has tumbled down the walls, when the bottom…
As gorgeous as the Grand Canyon is to look upon, its greatest gifts may not be visual. “On any given evening in summer, but most notably in late June, there comes a moment just after the sun has disappeared behind the rimrock, and just before the darkness has tumbled down the walls, when the bottom…
Kevin Fedarko & Peter McBride
13 min Read
Popular searches